Consecrated in 1880, Lodge St Andrew No. 651 S.C. was established by 17 founding members from a wide range of local and Scottish lodges, including Albany Lodge No. 389EC, St John’s Lodge No. 828EC, Pt Paul’s Lodge No. 989EC, and several Scottish lodges. The first Right Worshipful Master was Bro William Young, installed by Bro Alex Duncan, RWM of Lodge Kaffrarian Celtic No. 631.

Known as the “City of Saints” lodge, it has a deep-rooted connection to both local and international Freemasonry, emphasizing tradition, unity, and continuity. Notable past RWMs include Bro Alex Will and his son AH Will, Bro JC Rae (compiler of “The Tyler of 651”), Bros WE McLeod and S Pudifin (SA Bowls champions), Bro Lt-Col. Dr FA Saunders (first RW District Grand Master), Bro JE Miller (lawn bowler), and Bro EW Stoyell (lodge historian).

The Second Temple still exists in Grahamstown (now Makhanda), but is no longer used for Masonic activity. The lodge now meets in the Masonic Complex, Hill Street, Makhanda, and is a shareholder in the Grahamstown Masonic Temple Company (Pty) Ltd. Bro Bl Borman (PM) was among the first directors of the Company. At the Consecration Meeting of Lodge Caledonia No. 796 in 1895, most Officers were from Lodge 651.

Lodge 651 serves as the Administrative seat of the District, hosting lectures and educational activities at all meetings. Meetings are held quarterly in Makhanda on the 4th Saturday in February, May, August, and November (Installation in November). The lodge experienced a quiet period in the mid-2000s but now enjoys robust membership, including many Past and current RW District Grand Masters and other distinguished brethren. The lodge will celebrate its 150th year in 2030.